ProductGuidesPlay and learnToolsAbout
Get it on Google Play

Guides / Investing

Index Funds vs Active Large-Cap Funds: What the Evidence Shows

What the scorecards say about active large-cap funds, how cost and tracking work, and a rupee example of a cost difference.

Short answer

An index fund copies an index at a low cost. An active fund tries to beat it at a higher cost. On ₹5,00,000 for 10 years, an assumed 0.2% cost gives ₹15,25,415 and 1.5% gives ₹13,57,040. Past data does not predict any one fund. In Kubear you record the funds you hold, with units and NAV dates.

Key points

  • An index fund aims to match an index, so its return is the index return less cost and tracking difference.
  • S&P's SPIVA India Year-End 2025 reports high underperformance rates for active large-cap funds over 3, 5 and 10 years.
  • The same report notes that active mid and small-cap funds did better relative to their benchmarks recently.
  • Scorecards have limits: the benchmark, period, survivorship and category definitions matter.

What is the difference between an index fund and an active fund?

An index fund buys the securities in an index, such as the Nifty 50, in the same weights. It does not try to pick winners. Its return is usually close to the index return minus its costs.

An active large-cap fund has a fund manager who picks stocks from the large-cap universe to try to beat a benchmark. SEBI requires a large-cap fund to invest at least 80% of its assets in the top 100 listed companies by market capitalisation.

Both are mutual funds, with the same rules on NAV, redemption and tax. What differs is the approach and the cost.

What do the scorecards say?

S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes the SPIVA India Scorecard twice a year. It counts what share of active funds in a category underperformed a benchmark over 1, 3, 5, and 10 years. In the Year-End 2025 edition, for Indian large-cap funds against the S&P India LargeMidCap benchmark, S&P reports underperformance rates of 74.2% over three years, 84.4% over five years and 76.3% over ten years.

These come with limits:

  • They describe a group of funds, not one fund. In every period some funds beat their benchmark.
  • The benchmark matters. Earlier editions used the S&P BSE 100. Since 2024, SPIVA India has used the S&P India family of indices. Numbers from different editions are not directly comparable.
  • The period matters. Results move with market phases. The same report notes that active mid-cap and small-cap funds had a better relative year than large-cap funds recently.
  • Critics point out that the large-cap fund mandate covers the top 100 stocks while the benchmark covers a broader set. The scorecard gives the methodology.
  • Survivorship. SPIVA includes funds that closed or merged during the period, so the figures do not just reflect survivors.

You can read the full scorecard on S&P's site and decide how much weight to give it.

How do costs work in each?

An index fund's total expense ratio is generally lower than an active fund's, because it needs no research team. The exact numbers differ for each scheme. They are published on every scheme's factsheet and by AMFI. Two cost terms are worth knowing:

  • TER. The yearly percentage charged by the scheme and already reflected in the NAV.
  • Tracking difference. For an index fund, the gap between the fund's return and the index return over a period. It includes cost and trading effects. A fund with a smaller tracking difference followed its index more closely.

What does the cost difference look like in rupees?

Assumptions: both options earn 12% a year before costs. The index fund costs 0.2% and the active fund costs 1.5%. So the net returns are 11.8% and 10.5%. A one-time ₹5,00,000 for 10 years, with no tax, load or timing effects.

OptionAssumed net returnValue after 10 years
Index fund11.8%₹15,25,415
Active fund10.5%₹13,57,040
Difference₹1,68,375

Turn it around: for the active fund to match the index fund's ₹15,25,415, it would need to earn about 13.3% before costs, which is 1.3 points above the index in every year. Whether a particular fund will do that is not known in advance, and past outperformance is not a promise.

What differs when comparing the two?

QuestionIndex fundActive fund
What is the aim?Match the indexBeat the benchmark
What is known in advance?Cost, index rules, holdingsCost, the manager's stated approach
What is not known?Index returnWhether it beats the index, and when
What can differ from the benchmark?Small tracking differenceManager's stock choices, sometimes by a lot
What does it ask of me?Patience with index movesPatience with index moves and with the manager's periods of lagging
TaxSame rules as other equity fundsSame rules; higher turnover is inside the fund and not taxed to you separately

How do I read a factsheet when comparing the two?

A factsheet carries the facts you need. Here is a short list with example entries to show the idea:

ItemWhere it isWhat to note
BenchmarkTop of the factsheetIs it the index the fund says it follows or tries to beat?
TERExpense sectionThe yearly cost percentage for each plan
ReturnsPerformance tableFund versus benchmark over 1, 3, 5 years
Tracking difference or errorIndex funds onlyHow closely the fund followed its index
Top holdings and weightsPortfolio sectionHow concentrated the fund is
TurnoverPortfolio sectionHow actively the manager trades

Example of tracking difference: if the index returned 12.0% over a year and an index fund returned 11.8%, the tracking difference is 0.2 percentage points. Two funds following the same index can have different tracking differences because of costs and trading.

What about funds that follow other indices?

Not all index funds follow the Nifty 50. There are indices for other segments and for specific styles. Their returns can be quite different from the Nifty 50, and the SPIVA results here apply only to the large-cap category and the benchmark named. Comparing like with like means the same segment, the same period and the same plan type.

What are the common reasons people give for each choice?

People who prefer index funds often mention low cost, simplicity and the scorecard evidence. People who prefer active funds often mention the chance of beating the benchmark, a manager's track record, or a fund's approach to risk in falling markets. Each reason is a statement about the future, and none can be verified in advance.

One way to look at it is to write down what you expect from the investment: matching the market, beating it, or something else such as a smoother ride. The next step is to see which type of fund describes its aim in the same way, and what the data says about how funds of that type have done. The second step is the evidence part and the first is personal.

It also helps to notice what is the same in both: market risk, the need to stay invested through falls, the same tax rules and the need to review the holding from time to time. Choosing between index and active does not remove any of these. Many investors hold both kinds in different proportions, and the mix is again a personal choice.

What mistakes do people make when comparing the two?

  • Using the last one-year return of an active fund as a promise.
  • Comparing a fund with the wrong benchmark. The benchmark in the factsheet is worth matching against the fund's mandate.
  • Ignoring costs because they look small in percentage terms.
  • Changing funds frequently, which can trigger tax and exit load.
  • Reading a scorecard as a verdict on every fund. It describes a category.
  • Treating all index funds as identical. Tracking difference, tracking error and the index they track vary.

What can I check for my own situation?

  1. The category, benchmark and TER on the factsheet of any fund you look at.
  2. The fund's tracking difference, if it is an index fund.
  3. How the fund did against its benchmark over 3, 5 and 10 years, rather than one year.
  4. How long you plan to stay and what you would do if it lagged for a few years.
  5. What you hold already, so you do not repeat the same stocks in two funds.

How this looks in Kubear

You can record the funds you hold, with units and NAV dates, and see allocation across what you recorded. Kubear shows the facts and arithmetic; it does not suggest funds or rank them. Kubear is an Android app on Google Play. You type or upload a statement, review the draft and confirm it. Uploaded documents are read by an AI provider (Anthropic Claude) to build the draft, and files you upload are deleted after each reading attempt.

This is general education, not personal financial, tax or insurance advice.

Try the numbers

Step-Up SIP Calculator with Inflation

Enter a monthly SIP, an assumed yearly return, years and a step-up. See the projected value and the same amount in today's rupees at an inflation rate you set.

Open the tool

General education, not advice. Kubear Learn explains how things work and shows the maths. It does not tell you what to buy, sell, repay, insure or file. How guides are written.

Questions

Quick answers.

01What is an index fund?

An index fund buys the securities in an index, such as the Nifty 50, in the same weights, and does not try to pick winners. Its return is usually close to the index return less costs. The gap between the two is called tracking difference, and it differs from fund to fund.

02How often do active large-cap funds beat the index?

S&P's SPIVA India Year-End 2025 scorecard reports that against the S&P India LargeMidCap benchmark, 74.2% of large-cap funds underperformed over three years, 84.4% over five years and 76.3% over ten. The results describe a group of funds, vary by benchmark and period, and do not predict any single fund.

03Why are index funds cheaper?

They follow a published index and do not need a team picking stocks, so their total expense ratio is generally lower. Each scheme's TER is on its factsheet. Cost is one of the few things known in advance when comparing funds.

04What is tracking error and tracking difference?

Tracking difference is the gap between an index fund's return and the index's return over a period. Tracking error is how much that gap varies. A smaller tracking difference means the fund followed its index more closely. Both are shown on factsheets and fund house websites.

05Are SPIVA results reliable?

SPIVA is a widely used study that includes funds that merged or closed. It has limits: results depend on the benchmark, period and category definitions, and the benchmark changed in 2024. It works as one input, its methodology is worth reading, and it describes groups of funds, not individual ones.

Money, minus the managing.

Get it on Google Play

Money, minus the managing.Get it on Google Play